
Yesterday, I wrote a post on the Pew Research Institute’s projections that, by 2035, Muslims will outnumber Christians for the first time in the history of the world. I offered my thoughts on what this might mean for Christians, concluding that, for some, it will likely result in greater persecution, because Islam is growing fastest in those Muslim majority countries that are persecuting Christians, For other Christians, it will likely not mean much at all, since the lion’s share of growth in numbers for Islam will take place in those countries that are already majority Muslim, and that there is no country or region in the world where Christians are currently the majority that is projected to shift to a Muslim majority by 2070.
The bottom line is, though Muslims will outnumber Christians by about 0.2 billion in 2070, Christianity will remain the dominant religion in the West, and Islam will remain the dominant religion in the Middle East and North Africa, at least into the forseeable future. The great challenge in the West is not Islam, but secularism, as the unaffiliated, though losing a significant percentage of their share in the world population, will continue to grow in the West. They will not be the majority in North America by 2070, but they will not be far off, if Pew is correct, and if Christians remain satisfied that current rates of growth and decline, in particular by disaffiliation, are acceptable. Christians, I propose, ought not be satisfied with current rates of growth, and certainly not with current rates of decline. There’s been much written about the apparent wave of young people, in particular young men, who have been drawn to Catholicism and have joined the Church in recent years. I’ve contributed my own thoughts to the subject. But it’s still true that, for every one person who enters the Church in any given year, 8.4 leave, according to a survey by the Catholic University of America as reported to the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops earlier this month.
Why are so many Catholics leaving the Catholic Church? Catholic Answers, the apologetics organization lists ten reasons why people leave the Catholic Church. Many of them seem obvious:
1. Rejection of Catholic doctrine: they simply do not believe what the Church teaches. In my mind, this is the only valid reason for leaving the Catholic Church. If you don’t believe what the Church teaches, why be Catholic? One cannot force faith on anyone. At the same time, I don’t think Catholics who have left have given the Church enough thought as to why she teaches what she teaches, or respected Christ enough and His promise that He would send the Holy Spirit to guide His Church. Many who leave because they don’t believe simply decide that they don’t believe because, … well, for whatever reason, but rarely, in my experience, because they’ve given serious thought and struggle to the matter of what they don’t believe. I know one man who told me he left the Church as a teenager because the U.S. bishops changed which feasts would be Holy Days of Obligation. He figured, if they can make those kind of changes, they can change anything, and none of it counts for anything! Okay, as a young teenager (he said he was fourteen when he left the Church) I can understand how he might be confused, and I get that he felt there was no one he could ask. Teens don’t often tell their parents much, much less their priest. But, as an adult man in his sixties? Nah! Give it more thought, man! To leave and stay gone over the change in Holy Days? Pretty lame, if you ask me. Another guy rejected the doctrine of the resurrection of the body. Why? No real reason. He just thought it was absurd. Did he talk with anyone about it? Of course not! Why would he. It’s what he believed. Why should anyone tell him what he believes? Sheesh! I don’t mean to be ungenerous, but my experience with those who’ve left the Church because of doctrinal reasons is that they’re pretty poor in communicating why, and I can’t help but think it’s because they’ve not given it much thought. This includes Evangelical Protestants who leave the Church because they’ve become convinced that the doctrines of the Church are unscriptural. Well, have you talked with anyone about it? Have you discussed it with a sincere heart? Or did you set up a meeting with “Father So-and-So” loaded for bear with every intent of making sure he didn’t have a chance to get a word in edgewise? Please! Those who leave the Church because they cannot bring themselves to believe what the Church teaches after a long, prayerful, spiritually directed journey actually have a measure of my respect. I think they’re wrong, and I pray that they would make that journey longer still. But, hey, I’m not Baptist because I don’t believe what the Baptists teach. Same for the Methodists, Presbyterians, Lutherans, Episcopalians (extra-strong NO!), or any number of other Christian traditions, including Eastern Orthodoxy. Given that, I can hardly not respect the integrity of one who follows his conscience, even if it’s out of the Catholic Church. Again, just give it some serious thought, prayer, and study under the guidance of a spiritual director.
2. Moral disagreement: I have less respect for those who leave the Church for moral disagreements. Why? Because they are submitting to a subjective morality, and because the great majority of Catholic moral teaching is rooted in Scripture, not Tradition, so to reject Catholic moral theology is to reject the Scriptures. Nope. As a Christian, I can’t respect that.
3. Scandals and clerical failings: this is never a good reason to leave the Catholic Church, even if, God forbid, you have been the victim of such a scandal. You don’t reject Peter because of the sin of Judas. Period. Truth is truth. You would not reject that 2+2=4, even if your math teacher was the worst sinner on the earth. Truth is truth. The sins of her worst members do not negate the truth of the revelation given to us by Christ through His Church. It is chiefly our faith in Jesus and His revelation that makes us Catholic and keeps us Catholic. Why abandon the truth of Christ’s revelation for the sin of another? That’s giving another sinner way to much say in my eternal salvation.
4. Poor catechesis and formation: if one was not well catechized in the faith and morals of the Church, the response ought not to be to leave the Church, but to do what one can to be well catechized in the faith and morals of the Church. The number of resources out there that are good and reliable are so many the problem is not in finding one, but in choosing one! I would begin with the Catechism of the Catholic Church, a good study Bible, such as the Ignatius Study Bible, and The Faith of the Early Fathers by William Jurgens. Don’t leave the faith because you don’t know the faith. Learn the faith! Of course, many in this catagory leave the Church because they think they already know what the Church teaches, not realizing how poorly catechized they’ve been. That is truly sad. My prayer is that, before they reach the exit, they will meet a Catholic who is well-catechized who will address their lack of adequate formation.
5. Attraction to Protestant denominations: This comes down to a matter of faith in the Catholic Church as the one, holy, catholic, and apostolic church founded by Christ and which manifests the physical presence of the Body of Christ in the world today. One will be truly Catholic only if one believes that this is what the Catholic Church is. One will not long remain Catholic if one does not believe that this is what the Church is. Then it often becomes largely a matter of style and where one feels one fits in. Personally, I’m a low-life, self-absorbed, filthy sinner, so the Catholic Church is perfect for me!
6. Cultural pressures and secularization: I find it interesting that many young people, who profess to stand on their own, make their own decisions, and rebel against the dominant culture so quickly turn themselves over to the dominant culture which hates Christianity, in general, and Catholicism, in particular. I guess the old adage is true: “Young people want to be different, which is why they all dress the same!”
7. Personal grievances with clergy or parish life: this is no more a good reason to leave the universal Catholic Church than it is to abandon your career because you don’t like your immediate supervisor at this particular location. If you don’t like your immediate supervisor, say something or, at worst, leave that position and find another in your area of expertise. If you don’t like your pastor, or your parish, say something or, at worst, find another parish. Again, this is like abandoning Paul because Barnabas gives you headaches!
8. Conscience-based departures: individuals who judge, in good conscience, that certain Catholic doctrines are incorrect, so they leave. All respect to Catholic Answers, but it’s not clear to me how this is different from leaving the Church because one rejects Catholic doctrine. Perhaps they really felt that they needed to provide a good, rounded ten reasons!
9. Confusion about Church authority and Sacred Tradition: well, I guess it is true that, if you’re gonna be Catholic, you kinda have to commit yourself to that pope thing, and to the Church as the final authority on interpreting Scripture and defining the truths of the faith. Americans can be very individualistic, though, and I remember the days when people drove around with “Question Authority” bumper sticker. I always thought that was the wrong message. I don’t question the concept of authority. We need authorities. I question those who are in authority, about the nature of their authority and how they exercise that authority; which seems a far more correct attitude than just a dismissal of authority. But, again, Americans can be very “authoritarian” in regards to their own “authority,” especially on such “personal” matters as what one believes. Of course, the right question to ask when it comes to religion is not, “What do I believe about God?” but, rather, “What has God revealed to us about Himself, and about our relationship with Him, especially in terms of what is necessary for our salvation?” If someone thinks they can answer that question on their own, they’re not likely to submit to the authority of the Church. Of course, I would submit that making oneself one’s own magisterium is foolish in the extreme. How can you have confidence in your own teachings, and what if you’re wrong? This would certainly not make one a Christian, because sending the Holy Spirit to guide you in all truth is not one of the promises Jesus made. He promised to send the Holy Spirit to guide the Church in all truth (John 14:15-31). Remember, when Jesus made this promise, He was speaking to the apostles together, not to a particular believer. It is the Church to which Jesus sends the Spirit. See Acts chapter 2 and Acts chapter 15.
10. Emotional and convenience reasons: in these cases, the commandments of Jesus, much less the expectations of the Catholic Church, do not inspire them and do nothing to dissuade them from living the life they intend to live. This is one who simply does not believe in Jesus. Which, I suppose, is a genuinely good reason to leave the Church – that you don’t believe in Jesus But, as above, I would give it more serious and prayerful thought under the guidance of a spiritual director. We know, of course, that God exists. We don’t believe God exists. We know God exists. If there is a God, it’s not unreasonable to hold that He would want some kind of relationship with His creatures. If not Christianity, then what? If not the Catholic Church, which is the full expression of Christianity, then what?
Two significant reasons Catholics who don’t leave the Church but who also don’t attend Mass are youth sports and our 24/7 work week. Youth sports can be exciting, challenging, help young people grow in maturity and good values, such as teamwork, fair play, learning how to lose with dignity and, perhaps more important, learning how to win with grace. But youth sports can also be a challenge to the faith of young people and their entire families. There are families who will travel across three states to get their child to a soccer tournament, but won’t drive their families across town to get to Mass. For many families, quite frankly, if having to choose between a sporting event and Mass, they’ll choose their kids game every time. Andrew Hanson, writing in “Catholic Times” for the Diocese of Springfield in Illinois, tells of parents complaining, when the announcement was made that the sacrament of confirmation would take place at the diocesan cathedral rather than in home parishes, of the drive being too long and inconvenient. But when a baseball game for one of the Catholic schools was held in Springfield, many of those same families drove over an hour to get there without complaining that the game was too far away and too inconvenient to get to. Some families have an unrealistic expectation of their child’s chances of getting into the pros. A 2025 study conducted by the Sociology Department at The Ohio State University found that 17 percent of parents thought it was somewhat or very likely their child would become a professional or Olympic athlete. The actual number? 0.2 percent. That’s zero-point-two percent! Yet, those parents will risk the spiritual formation of their child because they’re convinced that their kid is gonna make it.
A second reason many Catholics who haven’t left the Church fail to attend Mass is the 24/7 work week. To be frank, many employers consider Sunday just another day of the week, and give little regard to the faith priorities of their employees. There are certain careers that require that workers be available on Sundays. Police stations and fire stations don’t close on Sundays. Hospitals don’t close on Sundays. However, even in these careers, it must not be assumed that the job takes priority over Sunday Mass if there are opportunities to do both. When I interviewed for a job at East Tennessee Children’s Hospital, the Nurse Manager informed me that Staff Nurses were required to work twelve hour shifts every other weekend, Saturday and Sunday. Given that I was applying to work day shifts, it would mean that there would be no time for Mass on those weekends that I was required to work. I explained that I could not do that because I had an obligation to attend Mass, that I had a family and a responsibility to my children to set an example as a father who attends Mass and that, simply as my own spirituality, family or otherwise, I was not interested in missing Sunday Mass for half the year. The Nurse Manager was very gracious. She said at the time that she wasn’t sure how we would work it out, but we would work it out. I think she knew I was serious enough about it that, had she said she would not be able to accommodate me, I would have thanked her for her time and moved on. Interestingly, when I actually started the position, it was under a new Nurse Manager. This was a bit exasperating, but I was cheered when she said she would honor the accommodation the Nurse Manager who hired me made. I suggested that, instead of working every other Saturday and Sunday, I work every Saturday and no Sundays. She thought that was a reasonable compromise, and that’s how I worked it for all the years I was at ETCH. Of course, I knew I had some leverage, being a nurse in the middle of a country-wide nursing shortage. The shortage has grown even worse, so Catholic nurses ought to appreciate the leverage they have.
The Catechism of the Catholic Church (CCC), paragraph 2181, reads: “The Sunday Eucharist is the foundation and confirmation of all Christian practice. For this reason the faithful are obliged to participate in the Eucharist on days of obligation, unless excused for a serious reason (for example, illness, the care of infants) or dispensed by their own pastor. Those who deliberately fail this obligation commit a grave sin.” However, even if attending Mass is impossible, that does not relieve the faithful of the responsibility to give God His due on the Lord’s Day. The CCC, para 2183 reads: “If because of a lack of a sacred minister or for other grave cause participation in the celebration of the Eucharist is impossible, it is specifically recommended that the faithful take part in the Liturgy of the Word if it is celebrated in the parish church or in another sacred place according to the prescriptions of the diocesan bishop, or engage in prayer for an appropriate amount of time personally or in a family or, as occasion offers, groups of families.” Illness, of course, would relieve one of even this obligation.
If there is a serious reason to miss Sunday Mass regularly, and it can be substituted for another Mass during the week or another devotion, then it is not a grave sin to miss Mass, even regularly, provided one has the permission of one’s pastor. We are Catholic, after all, and such a decision should not be presumed by the faithful. Speak to your pastor. Let him know your situation. Simply having a weekend shift cannot be an automatic excuse for missing Mass, especially given the plethora of Masses almost every diocese offers, even if one is in a career where one’s presence is essential. But there are many who miss Mass on Sundays whose jobs are not essential. It’s just that the boss wants to keep things going on Sunday because worshipping God is not a priority for him or her and he or she has no regard for the priorities of his or her employees. People need to make a living, of course. And I would not be the one to recommend quitting a job over such circumstances. Though neither would I have taken such a job in the first place unless my situation was absolutely critical. Occasionally, it is. More often than not, it simply isn’t. The Code of Canon Law, canon 1247, reads: “On Sundays and other holy days of obligation, the faithful are obliged to assist at Mass. They are also to abstain from such work or business that would inhibit the worship to be given to God, the joy proper to the Lord’s Day, or the due relaxation of mind and body.” We are obliged to abstain from work that would inhibit our Sunday worship. To me, that means don’t take a job if I know it’s going to require me to miss Mass on Sundays. Find another job. If it’s not possible, talk with your pastor. Bottom line: these are important decisions. A faithful Catholic ought not be making them without the consultation of his or her pastor.
Pray for the Church. Do not pray that Christ will be with His Church to the end. We already have that promise. Do not pray that the Holy Spirit will guide the Church into all truth. We already have that promise, too. Rather, pray that the members of the Church, the members of the Body of Christ, will have the courage, the perseverance, the fortitude to be faithful and to remain faithful to her Lord at all times, in all places, and under all circumstances. And pray that Christ will return soon. Marana tha! Our Lord, come!
Be Christ for all. Bring Christ to all. See Christ in all.